Restoration and home video releases
- Detailed: cinematic groundbreaker’s restoration and quality home video releases
- Shot in two separate versions: the Master’s final silent and first sound film
- The silent version was recently restored as part of the Hitchcock 9 project
- It’s a Hitchcock-up: long awaited first Blu-ray is sadly a distorted débâcle
- Quality releases are outnumbered by bootlegs; usual with British Hitch
- All licensed releases worldwide detailed for the first time anywhere
Note: this is one of 100-odd Hitchcock articles coming over the next few months. Any dead links are to those not yet published. Subscribe to the email list to be notified when new ones appear.
See Part 1 of this article for a full rundown of Blackmail’s origins, production, release, etc.
- Home video releases
- Soundtrack releases
- Criterion LaserDisc
- Yesterday’s Witness
- Related articles
Blackmail’s silent version was most recently restored as part of the BFI’s Hitchcock 9 project and transferred at 24fps (76min) but see below.
“Fortunately the BFI National Archive holds the original negative of the silent version. However, the negative had suffered extensively from ‘curling’ as a result of one side of the film stock having shrunk more than the other. This, in combination with very narrow joins between shots, meant careful digital scanning was required to prevent further damage and to make the film lie flat in the scanner’s gate. Without this, the sharpness of the images would have been severely compromised. Eventually, despite the curl of the film emulsion and the delicate splices, a sharp scan with excellent tonal range was achieved. The film is one of the first features to be scanned on the BFI’s scanner and it has benefited from the use of a wet-gate for sections of the film. In this technology, the film is immersed in a fluid at point of scanning in order to greatly reduce or eliminate the many fine scratches on the surface.
After scanning, which was carried out at 4K resolution, the negative’s remaining damage and several multi-frame tears were removed by digital repair. The intertitles were present at full-length – rather than the ‘flash-titles’ which often exist in other silent negatives – and have been preserved as part of the new master. The dissolves between shots are a crucial part of the film’s narration and, where possible, they have been reconstructed from the two separate shots. In the end, the restoration has produced an exceptionally clean picture which retains the essence, texture and beauty of the original photography.” – BFI programme notes
In 2008, Neil Brand composed a superlative orchestral score (spoiler vid) and he adapted it for smaller ensemble for the restoration’s première on 6 July 2012 at the British Museum. That venue is, of course, where the film’s finale takes place and made for a brilliant night! More pics here and here. The performance, by the BBC Symphony Orchestra conducted by Timothy Brock, was recorded in multi-track form but there’s no movement as yet on actually licensing it for release with the film. The score continues to be performed live on regular occasions, so don’t miss any opportunity you get to hear it.
Home video releases
As with the rest of Hitch’s British films, there are any number of very poor quality bootlegs, invariably of the sound version, that aren’t worth either your money or the time wasted watching them. Here are all of Blackmail’s official releases to date.
Silent and sound versions
- US: Kino 2-BD and DVD (2019) – BFI restoration of silent w/botched sound version; see below
- Germany: Arthaus 2on1 DVD (2002, reissued 2010, 2013), also in 3-DVD/4-film Arthaus Close-Up: AH and 6-DVD/9-film AH: Master of Suspense
- Spain: Universal 2on1 DVD (2002, reissued 2009)
- US: Lionsgate Prime Video HD – best available copy of the sound version; see below
- UK: Optimum 9-DVD Early Hitchcock Collection (2007, reissued 2016)
- Italy: Eagle 2on1 DVD (2005) w/The Lodger, also in 5-DVD/10-film AH Collection and 8-DVD/15-film AH Portrait
- France: Studiocanal 2on1 DVD (2008, reissued 2012) w/The Skin Game, also in 2-DVD/3-film AH: Les Premières Oeuvres 1929–1931 and 6-DVD/10-film AH: Premières oeuvres – beware: all films have forced French subtitles
- Spain: Divisa DVD (2003) pic
- Benelux: Universal 5-DVD/9-film AH Collection (2007), also in AH box set
- Scandinavia: Universal 5-DVD/9-film H Collection: Early Years of the Master of Suspense (2007) info
- Poland: Vision Film DVD/alt (2006)
- Czech Republic: Film X DVD (2009) – Digipak #71 (of 175) in ltd ed. classic film series w/6 US Hitchcocks; for rest, select “OBJEDNAT” tab and scroll down
- Greece: Studiocanal 2on1 DVD w/Chinese Box (1997) – newspaper giveaway
- Brazil: Universal 2on1 DVD/alt (2010) w/Murder!, also in 18-DVD/23-film AH Collection
- Chile: Universal 3-DVD Cine Negro (2009)
All pre-2019 releases with the silent version feature an older preserved transfer in decent shape, though not nearly as good as the sound version. Both run for 85 minutes (82min w/4% PAL speed-up). It almost goes without saying that the preserved silent’s longer running time compared to the BFI restoration’s 76 minutes is due to a different transfer method and speed; both are equally complete. I will say that however historically accurate it may be, the restoration has been transferred far too fast, making the actors’ movements throughout seem almost comical. Both silent and sound versions appear to be around 7,660 feet in length so I have no idea why the restoration is so fast; it equates to running at 28fps, rather than the BFI’s stated 24fps.
This is the only major issue I have with the otherwise brilliantly restored Hitchcock 9. Here, the slower-speed, preserved DVD transfer is far more natural and realistic. While perfectly watchable, the preserved silent shows many minor instances of wear throughout and is a little dark and dupey looking. The sound version, by contrast, is clean, bright and almost spotless. They also have different aspect ratios: the silent is 1.33:1 while the sound, like all very early talkies, is a squarer 1.19:1. This is due to originally being cropped along the left frame edge to accommodate an optical soundtrack. However, slight ratio variations are acceptable as long as the correct geometry is maintained.
For most fans, the German Arthaus and Spanish Universal DVDs are the best options available. The discs themselves are absolutely identical, with the only differences being in their sleeve and label art. They contain both the silent and sound versions with original English intertitles and audio. The silent has an excellent Joachim Bärenz piano score, while extras are a brief but saucy sound test take and an image gallery. They also have Italian, German, Spanish and Portuguese subtitles, and are region 2, PAL format. Most official Hitch DVDs come with a smattering of relevant extras but sadly, some that were previously released are still MIA. The same applies to Blackmail’s only known dub, produced in 1962 or 1968 for German TV by ZDF and Ifage Filmproduktion but still unreleased on home video.
Around the time the silent DVDs were being prepared in the mid-2000s, the Matrix Ensemble with Robert Ziegler performed a new score by Jonathan Lloyd at a few screenings. It’s sadly unrecorded and unavailable other than as sheet music but would have been perfect for the DVDs. However, the Matrix-Ziegler combo did at least get to perform and record a new score for The Lodger by the Divine Comedy’s Joby Talbot but so far it can only be had on VHS.
Anticipation was very high for Kino’s Hitch releases and none so more than for Blackmail, me included. But I’m gutted to report they’ve really Hitchcocked this one up. As per Kino’s pre-release publicity and the disc packaging itself, the BD was originally intended to be a single-disc affair like their Murder!/Mary BD. Fair enough: with two B&W films of 85 and 76 minutes, and a smattering of extras, it’s hardly a stretch for the format. But something clearly went awry and their “1.20:1” aspect ratio sound version has been transferred stretched to 1.33:1, noticeably distorting the image and making people look abnormally wide. The fault lies either in the copy supplied by Studiocanal or a mistake made during the disc mastering process; my money’s on the latter, as none of the previous releases are distorted in this way. It’s glaringly obvious that rather than go back and remaster the disc, and junk an entire defective run, at the 11th hour Kino opted to add a second disc with the 1.20:1 talkie transferred properly. Except it isn’t: this time it’s been transferred with a vertically squeezed 1.12:1 AR, making people look too thin. See Kino’s squeezed new trailer and these screenshots:
Studiocanal DVD: 1.19 correct | Kino BD: 1.33 fat, 1.12 thin
- Note: S DVD | K BD 1.33, 1.12
- Braban/Loder: S DVD | K BD 1.33, 1.12
- Museum: S DVD | K BD 1.33, 1.12
- Switchboard: S DVD | K BD 1.33, 1.12
- Roof: S DVD | K BD 1.33, 1.12
- Ondra: S DVD | K BD 1.33, 1.12
So Kino’s 2-disc set has three separate transfers – one too many – and two are defective. Sheesh. I doubt this will ever be corrected, though would love to be proved wrong. Instead, I predict it will continue to be quietly sold ad infinitum, as per Kino’s similarly slipshod Nosferatu discs. I can only recommend this insomuch as it’s the film’s only official US outing on physical media and offers the silent version in HD, albeit transferred much too fast for my liking. The sole significant new extra is an engaging, thoroughly researched audio commentary by film historian Tim Lucas, though it unfortunately accompanies the sound version(s). This was one of two simultaneously released titles kicking off a slate of Studiocanal-owned Hitchcocks. The other, Murder!, has a substantial pre-release-announced omission from its extras; my initial fear that it didn’t bode well for the rest of them was unfortunately well-founded but the saddest part is it’s so easily avoidable, as explained in my review for Kino’s also botched Rich and Strange. US residents should note that as of July 2020 Lionsgate’s HD stream of the sound version is still available – in the correct aspect ratio.
Edit: Kino refuse to admit there’s a problem and instead offered refunds for anyone dissatisfied. They’ve even called the knowledge of one of the set’s expert contributors into question; see comments below. This issue has been discussed on many chat forums, eg here, here, here, here, here and here. Amazingly, out of dozens of reviews, hardly any even mention Kino’s botched aspect ratios. Further proof, if any were needed, that most so-called reviewers either know little or nothing of film, don’t actually watch the releases in question, or are reluctant to criticise when necessary for fear of offending companies supplying them with freebies. So much for journalistic integrity.
Edit 2: See site consultant and Nosferatu expert Martin Larsen’s handy viewing tips in the comments below, to help you make a silk purse out of Kino’s sow’s ear.
Then there’s the silent version’s accompaniment; here a new one is provided by the Mont Alto Motion Picture Orchestra. I love what the MAMPO do and they’re easily in my top tier of silent film accompanists, but enlisting them for a score over Neil Brand’s existing one was a woefully misguided decision. Part of the avowed agenda of the much publicised BFI restoration of Hitch’s silents, coinciding with the 2012 UK Olympics, was to celebrate and partially “reclaim” him as a British icon. All too often, Hitch’s stellar, prolific career in the country of his birth is ignorantly written off as not much more than an “apprenticeship” and unfairly overshadowed by his later American movies. This then, was the reasoning behind commissioning a range of renowned British musicians of varying disciplines to breathe new life into his extant 1920s films.
Brand is one of the world’s foremost silent film musicians and his orchestral score for Blackmail is his masterwork. It’s the culmination of nearly four decades in the business and a real labour of love. What’s more, with it a version of the film would have resulted that could have been used for universal broadcast, home video and theatrical release, etc. As things stand, MAMPO’s score is pretty unlikely to ever be released outside of the States. Unlike many silents, Blackmail is 100% complete and authentic – remember, the restoration is based on the original negative. Therefore, Brand’s score could never be rendered redundant by a future restoration, and is unlikely to ever be creatively surpassed.
Why then, has this most British silent film, by our most British of directors, had the best score it’s ever known supplanted by an American outfit? The answer is simple: this release was ushered onto the market as cheaply as possible, and this new score is cheaper than licensing the alternative. But with just a little willing effort and cooperation, the cost could have been shared between several potential distributors. That way, Kino would have got it for even less and everyone, especially the fans, would have benefited the most. In case you’re unaware, the main stumbling block to releasing the restored Hitchcock 9 as a whole is the lack of funds available to record new scores. So releasing Blackmail this way is bordering on the criminal. And a huge missed opportunity. That said, taken on its own terms, MAMPO’s score can hardly be faulted, as it’s every bit as adept and appropriate as their numerous other silent film accompaniments. It certainly presents a generally more rewarding experience than the previous DVDs’ piano score, though of course the inclusion of both would have been even better. But that’s just wishful thinking, as the piano score was recorded to sync with a completely different (and more natural) running speed than the restored version.
We can only go on hoping that Blackmail, along with the rest of the Hitchcock 9, eventually gets a UK release, done properly.
- Preserved sound version – good condition, fine on all releases except US Kino BD and DVD with botched aspect ratios.
- Preserved silent version – good condition, fine on both DVDs. Joachim Bärenz piano score.
- Restored silent version – pristine condition but runs much too fast; fine on only release, US Kino BD and DVD. Mont Alto Motion Picture Orchestra score.
Now Showing: worldwide screenings
Courtesy of the invaluable Hitchcock Zone; click on any one and scroll through.
Note that all bootlegs only contain various poor quality copies of the sound version. All official releases are identical and taken from Studiocanal’s preserved transfer.
Sound version DVDs: bootlegs US Brentwood Home Video, US St. Clair Vision; Cine Korea| Official: Studiocanal
- Titles: BHV, SCV; CK | Sc
- Bed: BHV, SCV; CK | Sc
- L/O/Braban: BHV, SCV; CK | Sc
- Piano: BHV, SCV; CK | Sc
- Knife: BHV, SCV; CK | Sc
- Monkman: BHV, SCV; CK | Sc
- L/O/Calthrop: BHV, SCV; CK | Sc
- L/O: BHV, SCV; CK | Sc
Silent version: Studiocanal DVD | Kino BD
- Note: DVD | BD
- Braban/Loder: DVD | BD
- Museum: DVD | BD
- Switchboard: DVD | BD
- Roof: DVD | BD
- Ondra: DVD | BD
One last word on the subject of Blackmail’s music: there are many official full and partial re-recordings of scores from Hitch’s American films, but sadly not so for his British works. So far, there are only re-recorded excerpts from The Man Who Knew Too Much, The 39 Steps and The Lady Vanishes. Nonetheless, there are various Hitchcock film music compilations featuring selections from those and several other British talkies. But they’re almost all bootlegs too, mostly lifted directly from the film soundtracks themselves. The sole fully-licensed exceptions are:
- Museum Music 23-tr CD AH: Music from His Films (1999)
- Elusive Sounds 20-tr MP3 AH: Memorable Music from His Films (2012)
They include the “Main Titles/Prologue” cue from Blackmail’s sound version score composed by Jimmy Campbell and Reg Connelly, finished by Hubert Bath and Harry Stafford. The latter were also responsible for the score of similar film The Informer’s sound version, released just a few months later. The albums also have passages from Steps, Sabotage and Young and Innocent.
Since DVD brought about the demise of earlier home video formats such as VHS and LaserDisc, most of their then unique extras have thankfully been reused and recycled. The main exception in Hitch’s case is Criterion’s 1992 LaserDisc (spine #154) of Blackmail’s sound version. As the film wasn’t available on physical home video in the US until 2019, and then from a different company, its unique extras haven’t been ported across to any other domestic releases. Of course, if Criterion ever do get to reissue it on a more recent format, they’re pretty certain to reuse them. There’s not much chance of that anytime soon though, as in 2018 Kino succeeded Lionsgate as licensees for Studiocanal’s properties in the US. It’s a real shame that Criterion resolutely refuse to license out any of their redundant extras to other companies for updated releases, especially for their often brilliant audio commentaries. After all, they actually invented the format, and could establish a nice sideline in selling their spares as synchronisable MP3 files, as per alternative soundtracks of silent films such as Nosferatu.
- Sound Test (42sec) with Hitchcock and Anny Ondra
- Directing the Kiss (33sec) silent short with “Hitchcock ‘trying’ to show star Cyril Ritchard how to initially attack co-star Ondra. Hitchcock himself boldly jumps right in at the chance to demonstrate on Ondra, not only attacking but tickling her and trying to peek under her skirt.” Hmm.
- The Voice from the Screen (1926) Vitaphone demonstration short excerpt (10min)
- Audio commentary with Blackmail playwright and screenwriter Charles Bennett (still sharp at the then age of 91!) w/additional material by documentarian-film historian Laurent Bouzereau, spoken by filmmaker Stuart Birnbaum
- Sleeve essay by Bouzereau
“The Voice from the Screen” short also appears complete and in superior quality on several special edition releases of The Jazz Singer (1927).
Perhaps the ultimate Blackmail extra is one which has yet to surface on home video. Yesterday’s Witness is a BBC historical documentary series consisting of 50-minute episodes that ran from 1969–1977, with reruns until 1979. One instalment, “The Talkies Come to Britain” (1971), featured Hitch giving his only TV interview on the making of Blackmail. Other interviewees included Johns Longden and Stuart, who between them appeared in eight of Hitch’s films, beginning with his first, The Pleasure Garden. The programme was produced by Jane Oliver (1941–2013), who also conducted the interviews. It’s preserved safely in the BFI Archive and is currently viewable for free in the UK at any of the BFI Mediatheques. Due to potential licensing restrictions, this programme is only likely to see disc release on a region 1/B-locked and long overdue, definitive UK edition.
- Alfred Hitchcock Collectors’ Guide: Setting the Scene
- Alfred Hitchcock Collectors’ Guide: Miscellaneous British Films
- Free the Hitchcock 9! Releasing the BFI-Restored Silents on Home Video
- Bootlegs Galore: The Great Alfred Hitchcock Rip-off
- Alfred Hitchcock: Dial © for Copyright: British Law
- Hitchcock/Truffaut: The Men Who Knew So Much
- Alma Reville: The Power Behind Hitchcock’s Throne
- Alfred Hitchcock Collectors’ Guide: The British Years in Print
- Alfred Hitchcock: The Dark Side or the Wrong Man?
- Alfred Hitchcock Collectors’ Guide: Miscellaneous Releases
- Beware of Pirates! How to Avoid Bootleg Blu-rays and DVDs
- Charlie Chaplin Collectors’ Guide, Part 2: The Bad, the Ugly and the Good
For more detailed specifications of official releases mentioned, check out the ever-useful DVDCompare. This article is regularly updated, so please leave a comment if you have any questions or suggestions.