Bootlegs Galore: The Great Alfred Hitchcock Rip-off

  • Contrary to popular belief, NONE of Hitchcock’s films are in the public domain – anywhere
  • Years of speculation and misinformation by cocksure commentators muddy the waters
  • The most pirated classic filmmaker ever, with far more counterfeit than official releases
  • His British films are hardest hit, causing much confusion for fans wanting quality copies

Note: this is part of an ongoing series of 150-odd Hitchcock articles; any dead links are to those not yet published. Subscribe to the email list to be notified when new ones appear.

There’s something strange afoot regarding our Alfred’s films. Particularly those from the first half of his 50-plus-year career, covering his early British years and initial US movies. They’re often thought of as being in the public domain, but they’re not. None of them. Nada. This makes it difficult for collectors wanting good quality releases, because there’s a huge flock of viciously cheap ‘n’ nasty versions out there, blackening not the sky, but the technical excellence of the great man’s reputation. Join me for a terrifying tale of monstrous bootlegs, far more frightening than anything the Master of Suspense himself could dream up…


Contents


Will the real owners please stand up?

Ironically for the all-time Master of the crime thriller, Hitch’s films have been the victims of more crime than any other classic filmmaker. But who have they been stolen from? Let’s have a look at their historical copyright holders; since they were first made they’ve passed through the hands of various corporate entities:

Pleasure, Eagle, Lodger, Downhill, Easy, Waltzes, Sabotage, Secret, Man, 39 Steps, Young, Lady:
Gainsborough Pictures, Gaumont-British, etc → Rank Film Distributors (from 1941) → Carlton International (1997) → Granada International (2003) → ITV Global Entertainment Ltd (2004)

In the UK, home video releases have been issued by the following, which are essentially different iterations of the same company:
Pickwick Video (1982–1995) → renamed Carlton Video (1995–2004) → Granada Ventures (2005–2006) → ITV DVD (2006–2009) → ITV Studios (2009–present)
ITV have also licensed exclusively to Network DVD (later Network Distributing) since 2006 in the UK

Ring, Farmer, Champagne, Manxman, Blackmail, Juno, Elstree, Murder, Skin, Mary, Rich, Number:
British International Pictures → EMI (from 1970) → Thorn-EMI (1979) → Alan Bond (1986) → Cannon Group (1986) → Weintraub Entertainment (1987) → Movie Acquisitions Corporation (1991) → Lumiere Pictures (1993) → UGC UK (1996) → Canal+ Image UK (StudioCanal subsidiary, 1997) → StudioCanal Films (2012)

UK distribution: Optimum Releasing (1999) → StudioCanal UK (2006) – present, but home video releases didn’t carry the new owner’s logo until 2011

Jamaica Inn:
Mayflower Productions → Raymond Rohauer (from 1975) → Douris Corporation (1995) → Cohen Film Collection (2011)

 Releases: see Alfred Hitchcock Collectors’ Guide entry

Bon Voyage, Aventure Malgache:
Crown Copyright → BFI (from 1993)

 Releases: see Alfred Hitchcock Collectors Guide entry

American movies – this is a work in progress; please comment if you have any additions or corrections, especially for the titles in bold.

Rebecca:
Selznick International Pictures → ABC Television (1966) → Disney (1995) → present

Foreign Correspondent:
United ArtistsWalter Wanger Productions (1946) → Time Life Films (1968?) → Westchester Films (19??) → Shout! Factory (2014) → present

Mr. & Mrs. Smith, Suspicion:
RKO → UA (1971) → Metro-Goldwyn-Mayer/UA (1981) → Turner Entertainment (1986) → Warner Bros. (1996) → present

Saboteur, Shadow of a Doubt, The Birds, Marnie, Torn Curtain, Topaz, Frenzy, Family Plot:
Universal Pictures → present

Lifeboat:
20th Century Fox → Disney (2019) → present

Spellbound, The Paradine Case:
Vanguard Films → ABC (1966) → Disney (1995) → present

Notorious:
RKO Radio Pictures → ABC (19??) → Disney (1995) → present

Rope:
Transatlantic Pictures → Alfred Hitchcock (1956) → Universal (1983) → present

Under Capricorn:
Transatlantic Pictures → Bankers Trust (19??) → King World Productions (19??) → CBS (2000) → present

Stage Fright, Strangers on a Train, I Confess, Dial M for Murder, The Wrong Man:
Warner → Associated Artists Productions (1956) → United Artists Television (1958) → Turner (1986) → Warner (1996) → present

Stage Fright started out as a Transatlantic Pictures film but was sold to Warner in pre-production

Rear Window, The Trouble with Harry, The Man Who Knew Too Much, Vertigo:
Paramount Pictures → Alfred Hitchcock (1962, 1963, 1964, 1966) → Universal (1983) → present

To Catch a Thief
Paramount Pictures → present

North by Northwest:
MGM → MGM/UA (1981) → Turner (1986) → Warner (1996) → present

Psycho:
Shamley Productions → Universal (1962) → present

Alfred Hitchcock Presents:
Revue Studios/Shamley Productions (1955–63) → Shamley/Universal Television (1963) Universal Television (1964) → NBCUniversal Television Distribution (2004–present)

Suspicion (TV series):
Revue Studios/Shamley → Universal Television (1963) → NBCUniversal Television Distribution (2004–present)

Startime (TV series):
Hubbell Robinson Productions/Shamley → Universal Television (1963) → NBCUniversal Television Distribution (2004–present)

Full details on each film can be found here. A condition of licensing common to all legitimate home media is that the name and/or logo of the licensor or copyright holder must be prominently displayed on the packaging. Usually their ident is inserted just prior to the start of the main programme too. So if any Hitchcock film, on whatever format, is lacking at least one of the company names commensurate with the time of the format’s release, it’s almost certainly a bogus copy. Which brings us to…


A wolf in sheep’s clothing: beware the femme fatale

 Isn't she lovely? Don't be fooled – she'll only rip you off. The Pleasure Garden (1925, dir. Alfred Hitchcock) German bootleg DVD.

Isn’t she lovely? Don’t be fooled: she’s more gold digger than Gold Collection and will only leave you broke and miserable. This German bootleg is from SJ Entertainment, DA Music and/or Aberle Media. Take your pick: like many shifty thieves, they seem to be suffering an identity crisis.

Curious to see the rest of her immediate kin? Just look at these beauties. Very tastefully designed, with absolutely gorgeous faux-embossed sleeves featuring immaculate tinted images. Don’t they just ooze quality? Unfortunately not: beauty is only skin deep and theirs merely serves to conceal the ugliness lying beneath. Yup: because they’re all bona fide bootlegs. Their actual transfers look bloody awful – like they’ve been VHS-recorded directly off a 1960s TV screen. Also, these DVDs, like other unrestored Hitch silents bootlegs, are untinted B&W, cropped, edited, transferred at the wrong speed and the images bob and weave so much that watching them will make you seasick. As if all that wasn’t enough, they’re topped off with ancient muffled, generic canned music, as their many annoyed Amazon reviewers will attest. Naturally, most of the aforementioned applies to Hitch’s ripped-off talkies too. Elsewhere in this Hitch series, I’ve uncovered the provenance of many of his bootlegs’ atrocious transfers; the one for this particular specimen is described in graphic detail here. But be warned: it’s not a pretty sight.

It is a truth universally acknowledged, that if most bootleggers put half as much effort into the quality of their content as they did their sleeves, they’d have far fewer complaints. But they couldn’t care less: they’ve got a great, low cost business model that works brilliantly and attractive sleeves are their honeytrap. Once they’ve got your money it’s immaterial whether you’re satisfied or not. You’d think eventually folk would wise up and the bootleggers would go out of business, but no: there are always a million more unsuspecting buyers ready to be easily parted from their money. Then there are the repeat offenders: those who buy these awful things over and over. They either don’t know or care the films can easily be had in much better quality, or they keep spending in the hope eventually they’ll turn up the odd nugget. They won’t. What they will do is keep funding and encouraging bootleggers and pirates to stay in business, thus killing off the market for quality restored releases.

It doesn’t help when blogs and film chat forums are crowded with armchair experts, hell bent on spreading their completely misguided, even deluded, but always cocksure opinions. Perhaps the most egregious one of all is that they’re happy to buy some crappy release, to make do until something better comes along. But the very fact they’re supporting the bootleg industry makes that possibility far less likely. The more money bootleggers make, the more they’re galvanised into saturating the market with shoddy goods. Ergo, shoddy goods are all we’ll ever get.

Avoid this beautiful faker: she's a cheap German bootleg and you're better off seeing the back of her. The Pleasure Garden (1925, dir. Alfred Hitchcock) German bootleg DVD rear.

Avoid this beautiful faker: she’s a cheap old German boot and you’re better off seeing the back of her. The credits even come complete with the absent Nita Naldi once again misattributed as the Eingeborenenmädchen (Native Girl).


Pirates, pirates everywhere, and not a drop worth drinking

Every country worldwide is absolutely wallowing in homegrown Hitch bootlegs, mirroring the bewildering array of poor quality releases to be had from his fellow Londoner, Charlie Chaplin. As with Chaplin, fans had to put up with rotten copies of their earlier films – if they could see any copies at all – in the dark, dark days before widely available quality home video editions. You can learn, or if you’re old enough be reminded of, how bad they were by looking at the clips in any old Hitch documentary. Or via most present day bootlegs. Why on earth would anyone but a masochist want to put themselves through watching such garbage, when every extant Hitch film can easily and cheaply be had on great quality restored releases?

Owing to the ubiquity of Hitch’s British era rip-offs in particular, he’s easily the most heavily bootlegged classic film personage of all. That’s an accolade both he and his fans could do without, but never fear: if a particular release or label isn’t mentioned in this series of guides, it’s almost certainly a bootleg. I’ve certainly listed every official pre-Hollywood Hitch BD in existence. Sadly, owing to this rampant piracy, the likes of Germany, Spain and Australia each have just a tiny handful of quality official DVDs of his British films. Meanwhile, Italy has a sorry total of only three official releases. That’s it. In many other countries the situation is exactly the same – if they have any official discs at all. But those same markets are all awash with Hitch bootlegs. You see now how this works? Cause and effect, especially in the world of niche film releases on home video. Detailing all the Hitch-infringing labels to avoid would be impossible: there are literally hundreds of them churning out thousands of different discs. Though having said that, I previously compiled a substantial line-up of general offenders. There’s also a 2008-compiled list covering the first 10 years of US Hitch boot DVD labels kicking around the internet with over 50 entries on it, but dozens more have appeared stateside in the interim. Basically, the only licensed US DVDs of Hitch’s British films are from Criterion, Kino, Lionsgate, MGM and Cohen; all others are bootlegs. Another point is that while the persistent thieves are happy to bootleg or pirate actual films, they hardly ever touch any of their many extras. Mind you, squatting out space-saving, single-layer, plain ‘vanilla’ discs is par for the course with boots in general.

Most bootleg transfers of Hitch’s British films are derived from very worn and often edited 8mm and 16mm reduction prints from the US. These were show-at-home and TV broadcast copies, and often reflect edits made at the time of their original theatrical release or later, due to censorship or time constraints. They date back to the years when said films were in the US public domain, which they are no longer, and have since winged their way around the world. Where they appear on PAL DVDs, they’re always copied straight from NTSC sources – usually US boots – so additionally have the motion blur inherent to that slipshod transfer method. Many overseas bootlegs only contain a dub track, omitting the original English, and said dubs are frequently incomplete, being recorded for further-edited foreign release versions, making them even more likely to still be the transfers used.

Though Hitch’s British films endure the bulk of the thievery, almost as frequently the same fate befalls a seemingly arbitrary handful of his 1940s American movies. Even mainstream British newspapers have been guilty of transatlantic Hitch copyright theft. In those cases I doubt it was due to malice or greed; simply that the Hitchcock = public domain mindset is so ubiquitous no one bothered to pay due diligence before okaying their DVD giveaways. In terms of public awareness, there’s a lot of lost ground to make up.


Buy Hitch bootlegs and this is what you can expect:

Horror hides in the shadows: Eve Gray is stretched and cropped in The Lodger (1926, dir. Alfred Hitchcock). US St. Clair Vision bootleg DVD screenshot.

Horror hides in the shadows: Eve Gray is stretched and cropped in a shockingly murky copy of The Lodger. US St. Clair Vision bootleg DVD.

Murky: poor Eve is cropped again in The Lodger (1926, dir. Alfred Hitchcock). UK GMVS/Waterfall bootleg DVD.

Cropped again: poor Eve is cut off in her prime in this UK GMVS/Waterfall bootleg DVD.

The beauty: Eve is finally revealed in The Lodger (1926, dir. Alfred Hitchcock) US MGM licensed DVD screenshot.

The Beauty: Eve is finally revealed in this restored, fully toned US MGM licensed DVD.

Never looked lovelier: Eve at her best since she first shimmered in nitrate on the silver screen. The Lodger (1926, dir. Alfred Hitchcock) UK Network Blu-ray screenshot.

Never looked lovelier: Eve at her best since she first shimmered in nitrate on the silver screen. Restored and alternatively toned UK Network BD.

For lots more comparative screenshots, see The Lodger Collectors’ Guide.

Guilty, m'lud! Young and Innocent (1937, dir. Alfred Hitchcock) US Brentwood bootleg DVD screenshot.

What the… GUILTY, m’lud! Cropped and blurry US Brentwood bootleg DVD.

Not so Young and not so Innocent: Young and Innocent (1937, dir. Alfred Hitchcock) slightly better –but not by much. US Madacy bootleg DVD screenshot.

Not so Young and not so Innocent: slightly better, but not by much. US Madacy bootleg DVD.

Get the picture? Young and Innocent (1937, dir. Alfred Hitchcock) US MGM licensed DVD screenshot.

Get the picture? That’ll do nicely, sir. Restored and licensed US MGM DVD.

Pure as the driven snow: Young and Innocent (1937, dir. Alfred Hitchcock). UK Network Blu-ray screenshot.

Pure as the driven snow: Young and Innocently gleaming on the restored and licensed UK Network BD.

Of course, these screenshots only tell half the story: in motion, the bootlegs constantly bounce around inside the frame, making it even more difficult to focus on their already scratched and blurry images. Density and contrast fluctuate wildly from shot to shot and more often than not, they’re badly cropped and severely edited, losing up to a whole third of the original running time. Conversely, the official releases are clear, complete and rock steady, gliding along as serenely as a swan on a still lake. There really is no comparison. Read on for more real-life horror stories:

Part 2: Europeans make the best villains


For more detailed specifications of official releases mentioned, check out the ever-useful DVDCompare. This article is regularly updated, so please leave a comment if you have any questions or suggestions.

2 Comments

  1. Pedro
    July 16, 22:01 Reply
    Thank God I found this guide. I almost bought a Spanish bootleg Blu Ray of Spellbound from EBay. They are so easy to find!
    • Brent Reid
      July 16, 23:16 Reply
      Glad to be of service, Pedro – but watch out for the Italian bootleg too! There are only three legit BDs of Spellbound so far: US MGM (region 0, https://amzn.to/2DTdXxz), French Carlotta (region B, optional English and French subs, https://amzn.to/2C9NxqQ) and Japan MGM (https://www.amazon.co.jp/dp/B00PXI8948). Criterion are also preparing another US BD as we speak.

Leave a Reply

You might also like